Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
Food & Drink

Casamara is the Mediterranean escape Dupont Circle didn't know it needed

Toronto's Scale Hospitality and hotelier Jason Pomeranc brought their first U.S. restaurant to the new SIXTY DC this spring - and it's already one of the most compelling hotel dining rooms in the city.

Casamara is the Mediterranean escape Dupont Circle didn't know it needed

There's a corner of Connecticut Avenue, just south of the Dupont Circle fountain, where a dated office building quietly became something else entirely. Valor Development converted the Class-C commercial shell at 1337 Connecticut Ave NW into SIXTY DC - a 73-room boutique hotel, the brand's third address after New York's SoHo and West Hollywood. The building's transformation is quietly impressive. But it's what's happening on the restaurant floors that's worth your attention right now.

Casamara opened on May 23 as the hotel's signature restaurant, and it's already landed on the Washington Post's top 40 list. The people behind it are not local. That, somewhat counterintuitively, is part of why it works.

The team

SIXTY Hotels founder Jason Pomeranc brought in Toronto-based Scale Hospitality to run the food and beverage program - the group's first foothold in the United States. Scale was founded by CEO Hanif Harji and Chairman Terry Tsianos, who had both long been immersed in the hospitality industry - Harji doing consulting in Europe and Asia, Tsianos owning the Fox & Fiddle chain, The Wheatsheaf Tavern, and Palais Royale in Toronto. For over two decades, Harji operated some of Toronto's most popular restaurants under both Scale Hospitality and ICONINK, including Byblos, Figo, and Patria. The DC opening is Scale's first crack at the American market, and they seem to have picked their moment deliberately.

'It's, to a certain extent, escapist food, food that you may eat on vacation when you're traveling the Mediterranean,' Pomeranc has said of Casamara's menu. 'But, we bring it back around home, and we add local ingredients and twists to it.' According to Harji, ambiance is as critical to the SIXTY DC restaurants as the culinary offerings. He considers 'design, sound, and music' integral to a successful DC restaurant, and says that learning this market is one of the aspects of opening he's most eagerly anticipating. 'We're looking forward to being able to personally introduce the space, host a bunch of the locals, and just get to know the community,' he says.

In the kitchen, executive chef Zachary Albertsen runs both Casamara and the adjacent cocktail bar Reynold's. Before taking on Casamara, Albertsen served as corporate head chef at Scale Hospitality, with stints at Weslodge, the Drake Hotel, Wheat Sheaf Tavern, and Shook Kitchen. 'D.C. has such a great food scene, with fantastic local produce, farms and suppliers,' Albertsen said at opening.

The room, and then the roof

Casamara has more than 100 seats devoted to indoor dining, a 24-person private dining room, and a 3,000-square-foot rooftop overlooking the neighborhood. The design pulls from the same sun-baked coastal geography as the menu - earth tones, warm brass, materials that telegraph the Mediterranean without resorting to fishing nets and terracotta clichés. Behind a suitably glamorous façade, the hotel's public spaces take playful liberties with D.C.'s signature style, while the rooms display a more pronounced mid-century modern inspiration.

The rooftop is its own animal. Hours there run Tuesday through Thursday, 4 p.m. to 11 p.m.; Friday, 4 p.m. to midnight; and Saturday, 3 p.m. to midnight - closed Sunday and Monday. On a warm August evening, the view over Dupont's rooftops is reason enough to book a table upstairs, even before the food arrives.

What to eat and drink

At Casamara, housemade pastas, fresh-baked breads, rotating seafood, seasonal vegetables, and flame-grilled meats come together with the flavors of Spain, France, Italy, and Greece - sourced locally and, when the season demands it, flown in fresh from the Mediterranean. Standout dishes include sardine toast with avocado aioli, maple-brined Iberico pork chops, and octopus casarecce accented with nduja. Crab spaghetti and grilled lamb rack appear among the mains. The kitchen keeps things moving - expect the menu to track with the seasons.

The cocktail program at Casamara proper is worth knowing before you sit down. Highlights include the Pepperoncini-tini, a briny twist on a dirty martini featuring Grey Goose vodka and pepperoncini brine, accompanied by a feta-stuffed olive; and Donatella's Kiss, pairing Espolòn reposado tequila with Calabrian chili and ginger, sweetened with honey.

Around the corner, with its own entrance on 18th Street, Reynold's runs a separate and distinctly different personality. The bar leans Americana - wood-paneled, intimate - with a menu built around martini variations, from nouveau iterations to adventurous 'Dirty Secrets' like the Night Shade, a savory pesto-washed tequila and tomatillo brine martini. Small plates include Ossetra caviar with dill chips and mini burgers with pepper jam. Reynold's is a low-lit cocktail bar with a mid-century retro vibe - proof that you don't need speakeasy styling to create an air of hushed secrecy.

Why it matters for Dupont

Dupont Circle has had a complicated decade. The neighborhood still punches well on coffee shops and bookstores, but a string of restaurant closures left real gaps at the dinner-hour level. Casamara and Reynold's, together, fill a specific slot: the kind of grown-up, design-forward evening that doesn't require a crosstown commute to Navy Yard or a reservation sprint on Tock at 10 a.m.

The Canadian roots of Scale Hospitality are not incidental, either. Casamara and Reynold's mark the inaugural U.S. entry for Toronto-based Scale Hospitality, founded by Hanif Harji and Terry Tsianos - known for world-class restaurants including the Mykonos-inspired Toronto Beach Club, Middle Eastern hotspot Mar'aa Yorkville, and Miss Likklemore's, a Caribbean-inspired concept. Those are places built around atmosphere as much as food, and that sensibility carries here. The room at Casamara is designed to make you want to stay past dessert.

Already featured in the Washington Post's top 40 restaurants roundup, Casamara is participating in RAMW's annual Summer Restaurant Week, running August 24 through September 6, with a three-course prix fixe and add-on options from the regular menu. That's your lowest-stakes way to try the kitchen - though the Pepperoncini-tini is, by all accounts, non-negotiable regardless of what week it is.

Sources