Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
National Sports

Colorado loses MacKinnon and Makar to injury in the same game, and the Avalanche's Cup window just cracked open

Nathan MacKinnon will miss at least a month and Cale Makar is out two weeks after both stars went down in the second period in Ottawa on Thursday. Colorado was building something real. Now they have to survive without their top two players.

Colorado loses MacKinnon and Makar to injury in the same game, and the Avalanche's Cup window just cracked open

Thursday night in Ottawa, the Colorado Avalanche lost 4-3 in overtime. That part barely matters. What matters is the second period, when their two best players walked off the ice at Canadian Tire Centre, one after the other, and neither came back.

Nathan MacKinnon is out at least one month. Cale Makar is out approximately two weeks. Coach Jared Bednar announced both timelines Saturday morning, before Colorado played in Montreal. Lower-body injuries for both. No surgery news yet, no further specifics. Just gone.

The hockey world absorbed the news fast, and the reaction was entirely appropriate: this is a catastrophe for a team that came into November looking like a legitimate Western Conference contender.

What happened in Ottawa

MacKinnon's last shift came with 8:15 remaining in the second period. He had attempted a reverse hit on Senators defenseman Artem Zub. MacKinnon was seen grabbing his right side as he headed off the ice. He did not return.

Makar's exit was quieter and, in some ways, more alarming. He appeared to suffer a noncontact injury while coming to a stop in the Avs' offensive zone. He took a shift at 10:44 of the second that lasted only four seconds before heading to the locker room, then briefly returned for a 23-second shift, and stayed on the bench for the rest of the period. Nothing visible. No collision. Just a stop, and then he was done.

Making it worse: Makar's injury came four days after he left practice on November 8 for precautionary reasons. He had been playing through something. Now that something is a confirmed injury with a two-week timeline that could easily stretch.

The numbers Colorado is losing

These are not role players. MacKinnon leads Colorado and sits tied for fifth in the entire NHL with 30 points, on 10 goals and 20 assists in just 20 games. Makar is third on the team and third among all NHL defensemen with 23 points (five goals, 18 assists) in 19 games.

Both are on the Avalanche's top power-play unit. That unit has scored 10 goals in its last 10 games. Whatever Colorado built over those ten games, they will now have to replicate without its two engines.

With Makar and Manson both unavailable, defenseman Josh Manson is already on long-term injured reserve with an ankle injury, the Avalanche will lean more heavily on Devon Toews and Sam Malinski. Defenseman Alex Gagne made his NHL debut in Makar's absence, and forward Gavin Brindley entered the lineup for MacKinnon.

Bednar, speaking before Saturday's game in Montreal, did not sugarcoat it. "He's got a soft tissue injury, lower-body that he's got to deal with," Bednar said of Makar. "He's kind of been playing through it a little bit here, and it just kind of started gradually getting worse."

Colorado still went out and beat Montreal 4-1 on Saturday. Good sign. But Montreal is not Ottawa, and Ottawa is not Vegas or Dallas or Minnesota.

The shadow of last spring

Colorado fans have been here before, and the memory is fresh. The Avalanche were eliminated in the 2026 Western Conference Finals in a 4-0 sweep by the Vegas Golden Knights, a series in which Makar was sidelined for most of the games. They spent the offseason rebuilding around the assumption that full health would change everything. Through 20 games this season, it looked like it might.

Now they are back in the same spot, only earlier. A month without MacKinnon in November is not the same as losing him in a playoff series. There is time to absorb this. But if his timeline stretches, or if Makar's soft tissue problem lingers, Colorado could arrive at December's brutal schedule looking thin at exactly the wrong positions.

The Western Conference has no patience for vulnerability right now. Minnesota is healthy and aggressive. Dallas has its depth. Vegas, the team that swept Colorado last May, is right there. Every point dropped in MacKinnon's absence is a point that could cost them home ice in April.

What happens next

The Raiders will reevaluate MacKinnon as the month progresses, though Bednar said there is no surgical intervention expected at this stage. The front office has not been linked to any external acquisitions yet, though the trade market will almost certainly get a phone call from Colorado's GM in the coming days.

As of Monday morning, no further medical updates had been issued by the team. Makar's soft-tissue designation leaves the door open for a quicker return if the inflammation settles. MacKinnon's one-month floor puts him back around mid-December at the earliest, which means Colorado faces a minimum of four to five weeks of trying to stay close enough in the standings that his return still means something.

Gavin Brindley is 21 years old and had seven points in 18 AHL games before Saturday's callup. Alex Gagne is making his NHL debut. Those are the replacements. For now.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

How long will MacKinnon and Makar be out?

MacKinnon is out at least one month, while Makar is expected to miss approximately two weeks, both with lower-body injuries confirmed by coach Jared Bednar.

How did the injuries happen?

Both went down in the second period of Colorado's 4-3 overtime loss to Ottawa on November 13. MacKinnon was hurt on a reverse hit attempt against Senators defenseman Artem Zub; Makar appeared to suffer a noncontact injury while stopping in the offensive zone.

How does Colorado plan to cope without them?

The Avalanche will lean more on Devon Toews and Sam Malinski on the blue line, and called up forward Gavin Brindley and debuted defenseman Alex Gagne in their next game, a 4-1 win over Montreal.