Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
National Sports

Down 0-2 and banged up, Shohei Ohtani insists on playing in NLCS Game 3 tonight

Dodgers manager Dave Roberts confirmed Tuesday that Ohtani, hitting .150 this postseason while managing a right biceps and left knee injury, told Roberts he believes he can help the team win. Game 3 against the Brewers tips at 8 p.m. ET on FS1.

Ohtani wouldn't sit. Now the Dodgers have to win three straight or go home.

The conversation Dave Roberts had Tuesday afternoon at Dodger Stadium lasted long enough to settle everything, and settle nothing. When it was over, Shohei Ohtani was staying in the lineup for Game 3 of the National League Championship Series against the Milwaukee Brewers. He told his manager he believes he is close to finding his swing. Roberts, backed into a corner with his team down 0-2 in a best-of-seven, listened.

"He was very convicted that he is onto something mechanically with his swing," Roberts said Tuesday, per the AP. "He was adamant that he can help us. He's well enough to help us win a baseball game, so that's all I needed to hear."

That quote does a lot of work. Because the numbers behind it are not pretty.

The numbers are brutal. Ohtani doesn't care.

Ohtani is hitting .150 to 3 for 20, over six postseason games. He has seven strikeouts, three walks and one stolen base with no home runs, no RBIs and an OPS of .411. He hasn't homered since Aug. 18 at Colorado. For a player who signed a $700 million deal last winter and won NLCS MVP honors in 2025, those numbers represent a historic collapse at the worst possible time.

The injuries are the reason, or at least the explanation. Ohtani has been managing lingering right biceps and left knee injuries since at least June, which landed him on the 15-day IL in September. The injuries began to have a notable impact on his production in early August. He has appeared visibly uncomfortable at the plate while flailing at pitches.

Tuesday, he made an unscheduled appearance in the off-day interview room at Dodger Stadium. He took on-field batting practice, something he rarely does during the regular season. He was trying to show everyone he is ready. "The symptoms have subdued a lot," Ohtani said through a translator. "The symptoms shouldn't be the reason why I can't hit, and even if the injuries happen by accident, I take full responsibility."

Roberts had considered giving him a seat, the way he let Freddie Freeman take three days off in 2024. He said it wasn't about benching the Japanese superstar, but rather offering him time off similar to Freddie Freeman during the 2024 postseason. Freeman had a sprained ankle and bone bruise, took three days off spanning the NLDS and NLCS, and earned World Series MVP honors. The Dodgers know that script. They've run it before.

Ohtani, apparently, does not want to be Freeman in that particular story. He wants to be the version of himself from last October, the NLCS Game 4 version, three home runs, no runs allowed pitching. That guy feels very far away right now.

"In this big moment, we're listening to Shohei, and we're going to support the crap out of him and believe in him," Roberts said. "And that's it."

One win from elimination. The pressure on Dodger Stadium tonight is real.

Ohtani will be in the Dodgers' lineup for Game 3 of the NLCS against the Milwaukee Brewers on Wednesday night, with Los Angeles trailing 0-2 in the best-of-seven series. The Brewers won Game 1 by a score of 2-1 and Game 2 by 7-4. One more loss tonight and the Dodgers, the back-to-back World Series champions, face elimination before the calendar turns to next week.

Roberts said Ohtani will bat anywhere from second to sixth in the lineup. That range alone tells you how uncertain things are. The cleanup spot, traditionally Ohtani's home, may be occupied by somebody more reliable right now. While he began the NLDS hitting second in the order, Roberts has since dropped him to the cleanup spot. Now even cleanup feels like a question.

If Ohtani falters again, the Dodgers do have an option waiting. A benching would likely open an opportunity for top prospect Josue De Paula to start at designated hitter. De Paula, MLB Pipeline's No. 4 overall prospect, was promoted directly from Double-A Tulsa when Ohtani went on the IL in September. He impressed in his brief stint with the Dodgers, reaching base in half of his 42 plate appearances. He made the postseason roster and is ready if called upon.

The other side of the bracket: Tampa Bay evens the ALCS

While the Ohtani drama dominated Tuesday's headlines, there was actual baseball played in the American League. The Tampa Bay Rays used a three-run fourth inning to win Game 2 at Tropicana Field, 3-1, knotting their best-of-seven series with the Cleveland Guardians at one game apiece.

The man responsible was Freddy Peralta. In August, few people would have predicted his name appearing in any sentence involving ALCS heroics. The Rays acquired Peralta from the New York Mets in exchange for outfielder Aidan Smith, infielder Emilien Pitre and pitcher Gary Gill Hill. At the time, the trade was viewed as an overpay by the Rays, who were bringing on a pitcher who had a 4.99 ERA and negative bWAR with the Mets.

Tuesday, Peralta looked like a different pitcher. He turned in maybe his best start with the Rays, firing six shutout innings on 99 pitches. José Ramírez's back-breaking error, in which he allowed the would-be final out to scoot through his legs, opened the door for Tampa's three-run fourth inning. Peralta fired six shutout innings and three Rays relievers closed the game out. All-Star closer Bryan Baker went 1-2-3 in the ninth.

The Rays evened up the 2026 ALCS at one before the series heads to Cleveland. Game 3 is Thursday at 6 p.m. ET on TBS.

The broader picture heading into Wednesday night: all four remaining playoff teams are still alive, two series are now tied at one, and the Dodgers, baseball's most expensive roster, its reigning champion, its biggest brand, are in genuine danger of going home early. In his last 35 games, regular season and postseason combined, Ohtani is hitting .197 with a .629 OPS. The conversation Roberts had with him Tuesday was the most important meeting at Dodger Stadium in years. Whether it produces results tonight is another matter entirely.

First pitch at Dodger Stadium is 8 p.m. ET on FS1.

Sources