Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
National News

Trump's first-ever meeting with Xi and Putin yields a vague four-point statement, silence on Ukraine and Iran, and a split Senate back home

The Shenzhen summit produced a "Declaration toward Peace" with no mention of active wars. On Capitol Hill, Senate Republicans simultaneously abandoned Trump's demand to ram $350 billion in Pentagon funding through a party-line bill.

The first three-way summit, and what it left out

President Donald Trump sat down with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen on Thursday for what the White House described as a historic first. It was the first-ever trilateral meeting between the sitting leaders of the United States, China, and Russia. The session lasted 90 minutes. When it ended, the three governments released a joint document and Trump boarded a plane back to Washington.

What the document said mattered less than what it did not say.

The four-point "U.S.-Russia-China Heads of State Declaration toward Peace" covered plans to reform the United Nations, boost the production and supply of refined petroleum products "for the benefit of all nations," uphold "state consent and respect for immunities of state officials," and "conduct a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons." The declaration omits Ukraine, Iran, and North Korea.

Russia's war in Ukraine is in its fifth year, but it was not mentioned in the joint declaration. The statement made no mention of the wars in Ukraine or Iran. On Taiwan, Xi warned that leaders should respect one another's "red lines" on sensitive issues.

Trump told Xi and Putin they were "really making history" with the first-ever trilateral meeting between the three countries' leaders. He called the meeting "historic." Schumer finished that sentence differently: "Yes, it's a historic embarrassment that people will remember long into the future."

Trump met Putin and Xi in Shenzhen early Thursday for the 90-minute trilateral meeting on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. Walking into the room to greet Putin, Trump said, "He's my friend."

What the Kremlin transcript showed, and what the written text did not

In the Kremlin transcript, Putin raised the conflict in Ukraine. He said he had already discussed it with Xi on Wednesday, November 18, and with Trump in their one-on-one meeting. The written declaration still names none of those places.

Before the summit, Trump said he does not need Russia and China's help to conclude the Iran war. He had indicated in the lead-up that he would like to discuss the Iran conflict, the Russia-Ukraine War, and denuclearization. Neither conflict made it into the final text.

In the declaration, the three committed to reforming the United Nations to enable it to respond more effectively to global challenges. The declaration also reaffirmed their shared position that nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought. However, the declaration did not elaborate on specific mechanisms or timelines for implementing any of the commitments outlined.

As Trump met with Putin and Xi, U.S. allies gathered in Berlin for a separate "Coalition of the Willing." The leaders of Germany, France, Britain, and Poland, alongside the head of NATO, met to discuss support for Ukraine. Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen told reporters, "I think Putin will be even more emboldened after today's meeting. That is not a good sign for Ukraine."

Congressional reaction: sharp on the left, mixed on the right

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., denounced Trump's summit with Xi and Putin, calling it "a betrayal of the United States by a president who loves nothing more than to bow down to our adversaries for a photo-op."

Sen. Jeanne Shaheen, D-N.H., the top Democrat on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said Trump "without a doubt" got played by Xi and Putin during the first-ever trilateral summit.

Rep. Gregory Meeks, the top Democrat on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, questioned what Trump accomplished, warning that the meeting could undermine U.S. alliances. "I wish he had a plan and a strategy if he was going to meet with them and goals. Apparently, he does not," Meeks told NPR's Morning Edition.

Sens. Tammy Duckworth and Kirsten Gillibrand announced plans to introduce an amendment to defund the Iran war. Duckworth said "this is about ending a war that the American people hate and that Congress never authorized."

Sen. Tim Kaine, D-Va., said, "You can't" negotiate an end to the Ukraine war "without Ukraine at the table."

The White House posted the English text of the declaration on whitehouse.gov after the talks. Trump told reporters he rated the meeting a "12" on a scale of 10 and said the U.S. will not make decisions about the Russia-Ukraine war without including Ukraine.

Meanwhile on Capitol Hill: Senate Republicans break with Trump on $350 billion Pentagon bill

The same day Trump was in Shenzhen, a separate crack opened in Washington. Senate Republicans told the White House they cannot deliver the votes to pass a $350 billion Pentagon funding package on a party-line budget reconciliation bill, at least not now.

Senate Republicans are pausing Trump's request to pass $350 billion in defense funding through a party-line bill, choosing instead to attempt to negotiate a deal with Democrats, after facing midterm backlash over the Iran war.

"We want to explore all the possibilities for funding the military, one of which would be seeing whether or not there's an appetite on the Democrat side to do it," Senate Majority Leader John Thune, R-S.D., told reporters after meeting with Senate Republicans.

The main culprit: Republicans do not have 50 votes for a party-line bill. Some GOP senators think that if they do not begin work on a budget reconciliation bill before breaking for Thanksgiving, the effort is dead altogether.

Sen. Rand Paul has argued that the party would be tone deaf to pass $350 billion in new defense spending after the drubbing it incurred in the midterms, which saw Senate Republicans lose nine seats.

Deputy Defense Secretary Steve Feinberg met with GOP senators to explain the Pentagon's request and argue for the funds. The $350 billion is mandatory funding in the administration's $1.45 trillion fiscal 2027 defense request, which also includes $1.1 trillion in discretionary spending.

Passing yet another party-line bill drew concerns from multiple Republicans. "I'm worried that they're going to pass something that just is a clean $350 billion in spending with no offsets," Rep. Jodey Arrington told The Washington Post.

Senate Appropriations Chair Susan Collins of Maine favors the regular bipartisan spending process. Thune and Budget Chair Ron Johnson both told reporters a party-line bill remains possible if the bipartisan talks fail, though Thune said he could not say how long Democrats would get to cooperate before Republicans revert to that route.

Democrats are pressing for a short-term government funding bill to avoid a December shutdown and defer major spending decisions until they take control of Congress in January, leaving negotiations over the defense package tied to the broader fight over federal funding.

Although Republicans currently hold a 53 to 47 majority in the Senate, the upper chamber will come under Democratic control in January. That clock is running. "But everything else, I have no idea what we're going to do," Sen. John Kennedy, R-La., said after Republicans held a strategy meeting late Wednesday.

What to Watch

  • Ukraine and Iran at the table: Trump said the U.S. will not negotiate Ukraine's future without Kyiv present. Watch whether a follow-up diplomatic process emerges from Shenzhen or whether the declaration quietly expires with no mechanism attached. Sen. Kaine's floor vote forcing human rights accounting on Russia policy lands this week as a test of whether the Senate will put any conditions on Trump's diplomacy.
  • Pentagon funding deadline: Senate Republicans now have a narrow pre-Thanksgiving window to either close a bipartisan defense deal with Democrats or return to reconciliation. If neither happens, the $350 billion request could die before Democrats take the majority in January, forcing Trump to restart the effort against a Congress his party no longer controls.
  • Government shutdown clock: A December funding deadline looms. With the defense package now entangled in the broader spending fight, Thune and Collins will have to decide whether to link the two or let them move separately.
  • Sen. Duckworth's Iran war amendment: Her plan to introduce defunding language with Gillibrand will force Senate Republicans to take a public position on the Iran war just two weeks after the midterm losses the war helped cause.

Sources: White House | CNBC | The Hill via Yahoo News | The Hill | Council on Foreign Relations | NBC News | ABC News | NPR | The Washington Post | Semafor | Bloomberg Government | Roll Call | MS Now / CBS

Frequently asked questions

What did Trump, Xi, and Putin actually agree to at the Shenzhen summit?

The three leaders issued a four-point "Declaration toward Peace" covering UN reform, boosting global oil supply, restricting ICC jurisdiction, and beginning a dialogue on nuclear nonproliferation. The statement named no active conflicts, including the wars in Ukraine and Iran.

Why are Senate Republicans breaking with Trump on the $350 billion defense bill?

Republicans lack 50 votes for a party-line budget reconciliation bill, and several members are wary of approving massive new spending without spending offsets after suffering significant midterm losses. Senate Majority Leader Thune said he will first test whether Democrats are willing to negotiate a deal.

What do Democrats say about the Shenzhen summit?

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer called it a "historic embarrassment," while Sen. Jeanne Shaheen, the top Democrat on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said Trump "without a doubt" got played by Xi and Putin. Rep. Gregory Meeks questioned whether Trump had any clear goals or strategy going in.