Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
Pop Culture

Hollywood's hottest September in years just got two monsters fighting for it

'Practical Magic 2' opens this week with $40M-plus tracking and nearly 30 years of cult loyalty behind it. Then 'Resident Evil' swings in seven days later with presales already pushing projections past $60M. September hasn't felt like this in a long time.

Hollywood's hottest September in years just got two monsters fighting for it

Two big studio films opening one week apart. Both tracking for record numbers. One is a 28-year-later sequel to a movie that flopped in theaters and became a generational obsession on home video. The other is a reboot of a franchise Hollywood has fumbled repeatedly, handed to the one horror director in America who right now can do no wrong. September 2026 has no business being this interesting - and yet here we are.

Practical Magic 2 opened in North American theaters on September 10, and by this week's early tracking reports, Warner Bros. may finally have its first domestic $40 million-plus opening of the year. According to Koimoi, the film is projecting a domestic opening weekend in the $40 million to $50 million range - which would be Warner Bros.' first release of 2026 to clear that mark at the North American box office. For context, the original 1998 film opened to just $13.1 million domestically and finished with $46.7 million in its entire domestic run. The sequel is being asked to lap that total in a single weekend.

EmpireCity Box Office is predicting a $40 million-plus opening, while Box Office Theory is more bullish at $46.5 million, per World of Reel. Those figures are, as Dark Horizons put it, "a far bigger number than the $13.1 million the first film debuted to in 1998, even taking into account inflation."

The film has the full original cast. Directed by Susanne Bier, it stars Sandra Bullock, Nicole Kidman, Stockard Channing, and Dianne Wiest reprising their roles from the original, alongside new cast members Joey King, Xolo Maridueña, Maisie Williams, Lee Pace, and Solly McLeod. The sequel follows Alice Hoffman's novel The Book of Magic, focusing on Sally and Gillian Owens as they confront a family curse and unite to break it. More specifically, the film follows the Owens family 25 years after the first film, and when Sally's daughter Kylie uncovers long-hidden family secrets and develops dark abilities of her own, the women must unite once again to protect the next generation.

So why the sudden enthusiasm for a sequel to a movie that barely survived its original theatrical run? The first film limped to a $68 million global gross on a $75 million budget and earned mixed reviews - but over the years, it built exactly the cult following that now exists. Millennial women who watched it on repeat as teenagers are now the ones buying opening-weekend tickets. The sequel is expected to stream on HBO Max after its theatrical run, following the success of the original on the platform.

Then, seven days later, something else entirely hits theaters.

Zach Cregger's Resident Evil opens September 18, and the presale story has already gotten loud. Deadline reports the film hit tracking with an eye at a $35 million start, with first-day sales described as "huge," and the outlet notes that could push the forecast much higher - maybe even $50 million. That number would already break the franchise's all-time domestic opening record. At $35 million, it's the biggest domestic opening ever in the Constantin/Columbia Pictures franchise, besting the $26.6 million North American opening of 2010's Resident Evil: Afterlife.

Some trackers are going even further. According to Global Box Office, Cregger's Resident Evil had an excellent start in pre-sales and, driven by a large number of IMAX and premium large-format screens, is now tracking for a $60 million to $80 million domestic debut - the second year in a row Sony has given September a blockbuster-level release. Box Office Pro initially projected a conservative $30 million to $40 million opening before revising that estimate upward as ticket data came in, with the newest projections representing a dramatic escalation.

What gives this Resident Evil a boost is genre credibility and cineastes' fervor for Cregger following his Oscar-winning and blockbuster Weapons, which earned $151.5 million domestic and $270 million worldwide, per Deadline. The film is directed and co-written by Cregger alongside Shay Hatten. It follows Bryan, a medical courier headed for a drop-off at Raccoon City General Hospital who finds himself in a non-stop race for survival as one horrifying night collapses around him. The cast includes Austin Abrams, Zach Cherry, Kali Reis, and Paul Walter Hauser.

Cregger has been deliberate about what kind of Resident Evil movie this is not. He told IGN at San Diego Comic-Con that he is not adapting the games' stories or characters directly, explaining: "I'm not going to be able to do it better than the games. The games are so well executed, and to me, Leon and Claire and these characters, they exist so perfectly in the games that anyone I cast and any difference that I do with them would be, probably, to the detriment of what I was trying to do." Cregger also filmed Resident Evil for IMAX, per Nerd Initiative - a first for the franchise.

The production budget sits at $80 million, making any opening north of $35 million a strong sign for the film's commercial legs. The film is rated R for "strong bloody violence, gore and language throughout" and runs 95 minutes, according to Dark Horizons.

The pairing of these two films back-to-back is not an accident of the calendar - it's a collision of two very different audience theories. Warner Bros. is betting that nostalgia, female-skewing fandom, and prestige casting can convert a cult property into a real theatrical event. Sony is betting that horror auteurism, IMAX, and the Cregger name can do the same for a franchise that has never once punched at its actual cultural weight. According to Dark Horizons and Empire City Box-Office, presales for Practical Magic 2 suggest it could be a "minor hit" for Warner Bros., with little competition in September other than Cregger's Resident Evil opening the following week.

Both films are opening into a post-Labor Day corridor that studios historically treat as a graveyard. Right now, the tracking disagrees. Resident Evil is showing strong first-choice numbers among men under 25, with that demographic running ahead of comparable early tracking for Weapons, Alien: Romulus, and 28 Years Later, per Deadline.

The actual results for Practical Magic 2 should land by Sunday, September 14. Cregger's film follows the weekend after. Ticket counters are already clicking.

Sources