Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
DC Answers

How Washington DC is different from a state

Washington DC is a federal district, not a state. Its roughly 702,000 residents pay federal income taxes, serve in the military, and vote for president, but they have zero senators and no voting member of Congress. Congress can overrule DC laws at any time, something no state has to live with.

Washington DC is a federal district, not a state. Its roughly 702,000 residents pay federal income taxes, serve in the military, and vote for president, but they have zero senators and no voting member of Congress. Congress can overrule DC laws at any time, something no state has to live with.

The District of Columbia was established as a federal district in 1790 and is unique in that it is not a state, and thus lacks full voting representation in Congress. The Constitution gives Congress power over a federal district that would become the seat of government. That arrangement has never changed.

The Framers made a fateful omission: they failed to provide a means for representation for the district's future residents. In the Constitution, seats in Congress and votes in the Electoral College are all allocated among the states, but the district is not a state.

No senators. No vote in the House

Each state has two senators, but the District has none. DC doesn't have a full vote in the House of Representatives, and it doesn't have any representation in the Senate, which means no vote on Supreme Court justices, Cabinet positions, or really any measure that goes through the Senate.

DC does send a delegate to the House. For 35 years that was Eleanor Holmes Norton, who announced her retirement after 36 years as the nonvoting delegate representing the District. DC's delegate cannot vote on the House floor but can serve on and vote in committees, play an active role in drafting legislation, and speak on the floor. Norton could not vote on the very statehood bills she spent her career pushing.

Population bigger than two states, rights of neither

DC's estimated population as of July 2024 was 702,250, compared to Vermont at 648,493 and Wyoming at 587,618. DC has a population larger than Wyoming and larger than Vermont, both of which have two senators and a voting member of the House. DC's population gets none of that.

The nearly 700,000 residents of Washington DC do not have full voting representation in Congress, even though they are American citizens, pay federal taxes, and serve in the military. Those license plates that say "End Taxation Without Representation" are not a slogan for tourists. The phrase highlights one of the primary harms caused by the lack of voting representation in Congress.

Congress can kill a DC law. A state's legislature doesn't face that

On December 24, 1973, President Richard Nixon signed into law the District of Columbia Home Rule Act, which created a local government for Washington DC. The Home Rule Act granted DC residents the ability to elect a mayor and council, but Congress retained the power to overrule local legislation and DC residents remained without a vote in Congress.

The authority vested in these local politicians comes with a catch: the United States Congress has final say on the city's budget and laws, and it has exercised this power on numerous occasions, blocking legislation on issues including the legalization of medical marijuana and needle exchange programs.

Congress could eliminate Home Rule if it wanted to. Home Rule exists through an act of Congress, so lawmakers could repeal it or reduce its scope. No state faces that possibility. A state's laws can only be struck down through the courts or through the federal legislative process on a very narrow range of constitutional grounds.

Statehood is different in kind, not just degree: it converts DC's local authority from something Congress can override at will into something no other state's residents have to worry about losing.

The 23rd Amendment: presidential votes, nothing more

The 23rd Amendment, ratified on March 29, 1961, gave DC electoral votes. The amendment gives DC no more electoral votes than the least populous state, which has three. DC voters first voted for president in 1964.

The amendment treats DC as a state for Electoral College purposes only, not for other governmental functions. The 23rd Amendment does not grant DC statehood or full congressional representation. It is a one-topic fix for one specific problem.

The statehood push

A statehood bill would turn most of present-day Washington DC into a new state called Washington, Douglass Commonwealth. The new state would be on equal footing with the existing 50, with the same level of control over its own affairs and full voting representation in Congress, with two senators and one representative.

DC voters approved statehood in a 2016 referendum with 86 percent support. Norton was in Congress when the House in 2021 approved a bill to make most of Washington DC the 51st state. The bill stalled in the Senate and DC remains a district.

Under the Home Rule Act, DC residents elect a mayor, a 13-member council, and, since 2014, an attorney general who handles primarily civil matters. DC's courts and the office of the local prosecutor remain under federal control.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Does DC have any representation in Congress?

DC has one nonvoting delegate in the House who can sit on committees and speak on the floor but cannot vote on final legislation. DC has no senators at all.

Can DC residents vote for president?

Yes. The 23rd Amendment, ratified March 29, 1961, gave DC three electoral votes in presidential elections. DC first used those votes in the 1964 election.

Could DC ever become a state?

Congress has the authority to admit DC as a state. The House passed a statehood bill in 2021, but it stalled in the Senate. DC voters backed statehood in a 2016 referendum with 86 percent support.