Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
National News

Supreme Court takes up Trump's day-one asylum ban, setting up a ruling that could rewrite immigration law

The justices agreed Friday to hear *Mullin v. RAICES*, the administration's appeal of two lower court losses on its "invasion" proclamation, while Trump flies to Asia for a first-ever meeting with Xi and Putin.

The Supreme Court on Friday agreed to decide whether President Donald Trump had the authority to shut down asylum at the southern border by declaring an "invasion" on the first day of his second term, a case that two lower courts already ruled against the administration and that promises to be one of the most consequential immigration decisions in decades.

The grant of review came on November 13. Taking up another key aspect of Trump's hard-line immigration agenda, the Supreme Court agreed Friday to decide whether the administration has the authority to ban asylum claims at the southern border. The case is Mullin v. RAICES, No. 26-239. The Court granted the petition filed by the secretary of the Department of Homeland Security and other federal government parties in a noncitizen removal class case concerning the lawfulness of a presidential proclamation that limited asylum and withheld removal applications, and the availability of class-wide relief, but limited consideration to two of the three questions presented.

What Trump's proclamation did

On the first day of his second term, Trump issued the proclamation, 'Guaranteeing the States Protection Against Invasion,' barring anyone who crosses the southern border outside ports of entry or without required documents from seeking asylum or withholding of removal. Homeland Security guidance that followed barred migrants covered by the proclamation from applying for asylum and allowed quick removal without some of the procedures in federal law, SCOTUSblog reported.

The legal theory was blunt. The Trump administration argues that the president's authority to suspend entry permits officials to reject asylum applications from migrants covered by the proclamation. Immigration rights groups sued almost immediately. In February 2025, three nonprofit immigration groups joined 13 people in filing a class-action lawsuit against the proclamation and government guidance.

Two courts said no

The federal district court in Washington, D.C., and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit both rejected the Trump administration's proclamation barring people from seeking asylum by invoking Section 212(f) of the Immigration and Nationality Act and citing a nonexistent "invasion."

D.C. Circuit Judge Michelle Childs, a Joe Biden appointee, wrote in the court's opinion that while the president could suspend entry into the United States, as Trump and former President Biden used Title 42 to temporarily close the border during the Covid-19 pandemic, that entry authority did not extend to removals. The Circuit held that although federal law provides a president discretion in denying asylum claims, he cannot do so categorically.

The administration kept pressing. The appeals court heard arguments on November 3, 2025, ruled in April 2026 that the proclamation is unlawful, then paused its own ruling pending Supreme Court review. That stay matters enormously in practical terms. The justices agreed to review a lower-court ruling against Trump's day-one border asylum ban, which stays in effect while the case is decided by June.

What the Court will actually settle

The Court took two questions: is the ban lawful, and may courts order class-wide relief. The government's position on the first question is that the president can go further than past chief executives ever went with the entry-suspension power. The administration argues in its petition that the president has broad authority over asylum claims, which includes shutting down the system entirely because he has decided he will not grant any. 'The proclamation thus lawfully suspends access to asylum, which is a purely discretionary benefit. The court of appeals' insistence that aliens are entitled to file futile asylum applications elevates empty procedures over substance,' the petition says.

Opponents read the same statute differently. Their lawyers at the American Civil Liberties Union argue that the ban flouts the asylum rules implemented by Congress in the Immigration and Nationality Act. Keren Zwick, executive director of the National Immigrant Justice Center, put it plainly: "The Trump administration refused to honor its obligation to consider them for asylum. Even after the lower courts rejected the president's proclamation, the administration has continued to block access to asylum at the U.S. border."

The Supreme Court's ruling, due before the end of June, will be the final word on the Trump administration's sweeping assertion of presidential power over people trying to make asylum claims at the border, notwithstanding federal law enacted by Congress that lays out a procedure to do so. The asylum dispute is the third significant case on Trump's immigration policies that the court is considering, while the justices could take up other Trump-related cases in the coming months.

The ruling's collision with a changed Washington

The timing is not incidental. Democrats won control of both chambers on November 3 and take the gavel in January. Supreme Court decisions concerning presidential immunity and congressional investigations could complicate efforts by Democrats to investigate President Trump's administration when they take control of the House and Senate. According to The Washington Post, the White House counsel's office has added approximately 15 attorneys and coordinated with legal officials across federal agencies in preparation for congressional oversight.

Justice Samuel Alito was not subtle about the pressure the court feels. Speaking at a Washington event on November 12, he warned: "Congress can turn off the lights of the Supreme Court and stop everything from happening if they will not fund their activities." Congressional Democrats have also proposed changes involving Supreme Court term limits and the number of justices serving on the court.

Trump heads to Asia as the case takes shape

The president will not be in Washington when his asylum case begins working its way toward argument. Trump is traveling to China and Malaysia this week for annual Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation and Association of Southeast Asian Nations summits. Trump will participate in the first-ever trilateral meeting between the leaders of the U.S., China and Russia on the sidelines of the APEC Summit, senior U.S. officials confirmed. Xi is hosting this year's APEC summit, set for November 18 to 19 in Shenzhen, China.

Though Trump intends to discuss the war in Iran with Putin and Xi, he is not expected to bring up Ukraine, according to a senior administration official who briefed reporters on condition of anonymity in order to discuss plans for the trip. He will also meet with leaders of the Quad, India, Japan and Australia, plus the U.S., in Manila, where he will sign a trade deal with Thailand and attend the ASEAN summit hosted by the Philippines.

Analysts watching from Washington see the trip as much about domestic optics as geopolitics. After his party suffered a midterms hammering, Trump faces a new challenge: proving he is still the boss of U.S. foreign policy on the global stage. With Trump politically hamstrung as he enters the remaining two-year lame-duck period, world leaders may be quietly wondering how to leverage the new balance of power in Washington. Trump's errant war of choice and its effect on energy prices were the principal cause of the midterm rout of Republicans. Vice President JD Vance admitted as much: 'The reason we lost is the war.'

Kurt Campbell, chair of The Asia Group and a senior diplomat in the Biden administration, was more pointed about the summit's symbolic weight. The bigger goal for Trump may well be a single photo of himself standing with the two other leaders he views as his great power equals.

Meanwhile, the Dec. 11 government funding deadline sits waiting. Lawmakers in both chambers must negotiate a deal to avoid a government shutdown. Government funding is set to lapse December 11. And Congress's first order of business when members return to Capitol Hill this week will be an Nvidia-related cloud that has not cleared. Lawmakers are returning with questions surrounding Nvidia and the resignation of CEO Jensen Huang. Huang and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick have agreed to testify before congressional committees as the fallout continues.

What to Watch

  • Argument date in Mullin v. RAICES: The Supreme Court granted the government's petition to hear the case, and argument is expected in spring 2027. Watch for the Court to set a date in its December conference orders, and for both sides to file briefs that will define whether the "invasion" framing survives strict legal scrutiny.
  • Trump-Xi-Putin trilateral, November 19: The trilateral meeting is the most unusual development. Trump has said he wants to discuss denuclearization with Xi and Putin, and American officials say the talks will focus on Iran and will not address Russia's war in Ukraine. Any joint statement, or the absence of one, will land back in Washington as evidence of Trump's post-midterm leverage, or lack of it.
  • Shutdown clock: With the Dec. 11 deadline approaching and a lame-duck Republican majority on its way out, watch whether House Speaker and Senate leadership can agree on a continuing resolution before the holiday recess compresses the schedule further.
  • Iran war resolutions: Gregory Meeks has said he intends to bring resolutions to the floor to end the Iran war and to reclaim congressional authority over foreign policy once Democrats hold the gavel in January. The Shenzhen talks could either give Trump diplomatic cover, or box him in further.

Sources: The Washington Post | NBC News | SCOTUSblog | Roll Call | ACLU of DC | Courthouse News Service | ABC News | Bloomberg | Foreign Policy | NBC News (Alito remarks)

Frequently asked questions

What is the Supreme Court being asked to decide?

The justices will rule on two questions: whether Trump's January 2025 proclamation declaring an "invasion" and suspending asylum was lawful, and whether courts can grant class-wide relief to asylum seekers. What happens to the asylum ban while the case is pending? :: The D.C. Circuit paused its own ruling against the ban, so the restrictions remain in effect while the Supreme Court considers the appeal; a decision is expected before the end of June 2027. What does Trump's Asia trip have to do with the asylum case? :: Both stories reflect the same lame-duck dynamic: a president shorn of congressional support is leaning on executive power and foreign-policy summitry, while a newly Democratic Congress preparing to take over in January plans investigations of his immigration record.>