Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
Pop Culture

Ryan Murphy's new 'Monster' is the biggest show on Netflix and critics mostly hate it

'The Lizzie Borden Story' debuted to 12.1 million views in its first week despite a 42% Rotten Tomatoes score, and the gap between audience numbers and critical contempt is the most Ryan Murphy thing imaginable.

Ryan Murphy's new 'Monster' is the biggest show on Netflix and critics mostly hate it

Ryan Murphy's formula is back, and it is working exactly as designed, which is to say, the new season of Monster is crushing the global charts while critics sharpen their knives. Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story dropped all eight episodes on September 17 and became the No. 1 show on Netflix worldwide within 48 hours. Numbers confirm what the discourse has been screaming all week.

Per Netflix's own Tudum data, the series raked in 12.1 million views for the week of September 14 to 20, and considering all eight episodes didn't drop until September 17, that debut window covered only four days of actual availability, accumulating a total of 80.1 million hours watched. That's a number most shows never touch in their entire run.

According to Deadline, the 12.1 million views for that debut period appears on par with last season's premiere weekend for The Ed Gein Story, though that prior installment launched to somewhat warmer reviews. The franchise's momentum is intact. Its critical reputation, less so.

The worst scores in Monster history, the biggest numbers anyway

The season is the fourth installment of the anthology, created by Ian Brennan for Netflix, and centers on murder suspect Lizzie Borden, played by Ella Beatty, who was tried and acquitted of the 1892 axe murders of her father and stepmother in Fall River, Massachusetts. It is also the first installment of the anthology to focus on an alleged female perpetrator.

Rotten Tomatoes reports a 42% approval rating based on 19 critic reviews, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 10. Metacritic gives it a score of 47 out of 100, indicating "mixed or average" reviews. The audience score on Rotten Tomatoes sits at a disappointing 35%, lower than Ed Gein's 49%, Lyle and Erik Menendez's 57%, and Dahmer's 82%, making it the lowest-rated entry across the board. Every season has been panned. Every season has been enormous anyway.

The Monster anthology turned Jeffrey Dahmer into one of the most-viewed figures in Netflix history while drawing complaints from victims' families, and then did it all again with the Menendez brothers and Ed Gein. Each installment has been accused of glamorizing its subject, and each has been enormous anyway.

What the critics actually said

The reviews are not uniformly terrible. They're divided, sometimes loudly. Variety's Aramide Tinubu called the season "highly watchable" and said it "offers something refreshing and wholly unique" to the Monster franchise. The Guardian was less enthusiastic overall but praised the show's style and energy, calling it "absolutely full of great performances," with critic Lucy Mangan also noting that the series has "an almost Wes Anderson feel at times."

The Wrap landed somewhere between admiration and bewilderment. At times, the review notes, the show "feels like a bunch of talented performers turned loose in an exceptionally expensive gothic playground." Rebecca Hall in particular impressed TheWrap, which called her "the real scene-stealer." RogerEbert.com pointed to a specific creative choice that bothered several critics: the show ages Borden down and portrays her as neurodivergent, which the review argues may be "the show's first big misstep."

Gold Derby noted that while previous Monster seasons faced mostly ethical objections, reviews aren't convinced that Murphy, Brennan, and Beatty pulled off the shift to a female protagonist. That said, Gold Derby also quoted Sean T. Collins praising the show for indulging audience fascination with famous killers and the details of their crimes.

Who is Ella Beatty, and why does this role matter?

Beatty is 23 years old and the daughter of Warren Beatty and Annette Bening. After an extensive search, Murphy and Brennan chose her to bring Lizzie to life; she previously appeared in Murphy's Feud: Capote vs. The Swans and can also be seen in Mary Bronstein's Oscar-nominated Sundance film If I Had Legs I'd Kick You. Monster is far and away her highest-profile role to date, and the performance has split reviewers almost as sharply as the show itself.

Beatty has described her character as a "very fictionalized version" of the real Borden, which is the diplomatic way of acknowledging what the show freely admits: it is not a documentary. The season also features Sarah Paulson as Aileen Wuornos, the Florida serial killer who lived nearly a century after Borden, a structurally strange choice that critics have flagged as either inspired or incoherent, depending on whom you ask.

According to Vanity Fair, creator Ian Brennan described the season as exploring misogyny, gender roles, and societal expectations placed on Victorian-era women. The show also examines class and sexuality themes through the relationship between Borden and housemaid Bridget Sullivan. It is not a faithful retelling: there is no definite historical evidence that Borden and Sullivan were lovers.

What's next for the franchise?

Netflix has yet to officially renew the anthology for another season, but Murphy and showrunner Ian Brennan have said that Monster could run for at least ten seasons, with figures such as Dennis Rader, Gary Ridgway, and Ted Bundy all being explored in future entries. According to Netflix, the Monster franchise as a whole has reached nearly 170 million views across all seasons. At that scale, the renewal conversation is probably a formality.

On the current Netflix chart for September 14 to 20, Crew Girl followed The Lizzie Borden Story in the No. 2 spot with 11.3 million views, doubling the 5.2 million it achieved in its debut week. Monster held the top slot by a margin, but Crew Girl's surge is the other streaming story worth watching heading into fall.

The show's eight episodes are all streaming now. Vicky Krieps is in it. The axes are period-accurate. Sarah Paulson shows up as a Florida serial killer for reasons the season will explain. Whether or not that makes sense is, at this point, a matter of personal taste and tolerance for Ryan Murphy doing what Ryan Murphy does at full volume.

Sources