Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
Culture

The Last Night of High School: How Gregory Pellerito Turned a Scavenger Hunt Into “Moments of Youth”

The Fairfield County writer-director on John Hughes, a table read that stopped the room, and why the biggest prize was never the money.

Everybody remembers the last night before everything changes. Gregory Pellerito built a whole movie inside one.

"Moments of Youth" takes place the night before a high school class graduates. The school runs an enormous scavenger hunt every year, and this time the prize is the largest in its history. Over the course of that single night, a group of friends throws itself into a string of outrageous, adventurous, and genuinely funny tasks, and somewhere between the challenges, you start to learn who these kids actually are, what brought them to this point, and what they are walking toward. For the first two thirds, the film keeps hinting at something deeper underneath all the chaos. Then it arrives, the friends face a traumatic event they have been carrying, and the night becomes the way they finally move forward.

It is a comedy with a lump in its throat, and that is exactly what Pellerito was after.

"There's just something so charming about high school ending," he said. "This fleeting feeling of engulfing the last four years and holding onto it, while simultaneously feeling that excitement and, in most cases, nervousness, about the uncertainty of the future. It's as pure of a moment in time as people can have."

A film in the vein of the ones he loves

Pellerito has always been drawn to stories that unfold across one day or one night. He calls them a slice of life, and he liked that a scavenger hunt with a deadline hands you the tempo for free. "It automatically lends itself to a highly intense, mile-a-minute tone," he said. Inside that truncated timeline, he gets to pack a lifetime of events and memories for his characters into a few hours.

The DNA here is not hard to trace, and Pellerito names it happily. The classic John Hughes films. The teen comedies of the 90s. Ferris Bueller's Day Off, The Breakfast Club, American Pie, Can't Hardly Wait. "I wanted to make a film in the vein of the films I love so much," he said.

The run it is having suggests the love translated. "Moments of Youth" has earned 40 awards, played 35 festivals, and drawn coverage from more than 200 publications, with a cast that includes Cheri Oteri, John Farley, Garry Pastore, and Betsy Beutler.

Carson, Darcy, Principal Crenshaw (John Farley), and Jemma in “Moments of Youth.” Courtesy of Jackpot Pictures.

The theme underneath the hunt

Ask Pellerito what he wants people to carry out of the theater and the comedy falls away for a second.

"There are a few primary themes," he said. "The first is friendship. No matter how difficult of a situation you might be in, your family and friends are the ones who will help guide you through it." He loves that his characters become underdogs, and that audiences love an underdog. They chase a pile of money all night and realize the night was about anything but that.

He points to a line one of his characters, Carson, delivers near the end: "As long as we have each other, we have forever."

"I think this sums it up," Pellerito said. "Lean on and rely on those you love to help you, because they will. And even the hardest, most traumatic event, you will make it through."

He knew the film had that second gear early. The moment came at the cast table read, when the actors reached the scene where the friends finally talk about what happened. "When we finished the scene, it went completely silent for several minutes," he said. "The majority of us were in tears. I said that we need to take a break, and we did. But it was in that moment that I knew we had a very special film."

The friends Pellerito calls Commonwealth Court. Courtesy of Jackpot Pictures.

Writing it, directing it, and leaving room to play

Pellerito has only ever directed projects he wrote himself, and he likes it that way. "I literally envision the scene exactly the way I want it to play out, as well as its style and tone, as I'm writing it," he said. "So in a way, I'm capturing it in my mind as I'm creating it initially."

He is quick to add that he does not want to stop at his own scripts. He is excited by the chance to direct work that started on someone else's page. "There are so many talented writers out there," he said, "and I look forward to directing pieces that others have written."

That does not make him precious about the page. The foundation of the script held all the way through production, but Pellerito is a devoted believer in improvisation, and he invites ideas from everyone on set, from his lead actors to the interns. "There are a lot of talented people on a film. It would be a huge disservice not to capitalize on their ideas," he said. With a comedy, it helps that a lot of those people are very funny.

His favorite example lives in a scene between Principal Crenshaw, played by John Farley, and a student named Brianna. "John Farley is a master of improv. He is just so quick-witted," Pellerito said. He pulled Farley aside and cooked up a bit without telling the actress playing Brianna. In the take, Crenshaw mentions that the restaurant she claims to work at has burned down, and her stunned reaction is completely real because she had no idea it was coming. "This is one of my favorite scenes in the movie," he said, "and I think it is one of the funniest."

Cheri Oteri, Julia Tolchin, and Garry Pastore in “Moments of Youth.” Courtesy of Jackpot Pictures.

An ensemble that feels like a real friend group

The thing Pellerito most wanted from his young cast was authenticity, the sense that these characters have known each other forever. He got it. The group he calls the Shady Ladies plays like four girlfriends who grew up together. "Their chemistry is one of the strongest assets that helps carry the film," he said. "They finish each other's sentences. They talk over each other. They even make fun of each other the way best friends tease one another." The same goes for the crew he calls Commonwealth Court, a set of very different characters who lock together into one unit.

Finding that group during a pandemic was its own feat. The first round of auditions happened virtually, with young actors filming themselves in scenes Pellerito chose for each character. The submissions poured in by the thousands. "Every young actor in the country wanted to be in the film, and we saw a cascade of talent," he said. Live Zoom reads narrowed the field, and a callback session in Manhattan sealed the young cast. The named talent came on through direct offers, with producers who had worked with each of them before.

Why Connecticut

"Moments of Youth" was shot across Connecticut, mostly in Fairfield County, where Pellerito is from and still lives. That was not the original plan. The film was first set in Myrtle Beach and written specifically for that area. Then COVID arrived, and the whole world felt uncertain. So he rewrote the story for home, where he understood the protocols and restrictions better than anywhere else, with every intention of rolling cameras the moment things opened up.

Home turned out to be a gift. "Connecticut is beautiful and we have everything here: suburbs, inner city, gorgeous beaches, country," he said. "I think the landscape of the state, namely the coastline, gives the film a lovely tone and feel. Summer on the water." Shooting in places the team knew well helped a production that already had plenty to manage, from PCR tests every 48 hours to a COVID compliance officer on set every single day.

Writer-director Gregory Pellerito. Courtesy of Jackpot Pictures.

Jackpot Pictures, and what comes next

Pellerito runs Jackpot Pictures, and the company has a clear north star. "Our main mission is to tell stories that truly say something profound," he said. Production value matters to him, but never more than the story and its message. He wants to make films that give people something to root for and send them out of the theater with a little more hope than they walked in with. "Moments of Youth" sits right in the center of that. Heartfelt, nostalgic, warm.

He is not slowing down. Pellerito is preparing his next film, a drama comedy titled "The Final Score," and developing two television series, one a comedy drama and one a thriller. He has another 10 films in active development, and a hidden camera game show he created, "Everyone Has Their Price," was recently acquired and will stream soon. He also says he writes tighter now than he used to. "Early on, I would use seven or eight pages to make a point that I likely say in just one now," he said. He credits editing "Moments of Youth" for the lesson.

A quieter beat on the Connecticut coast. Courtesy of Jackpot Pictures.

Where to watch

"Moments of Youth" is widely available. It streams in the US and UK on Amazon, in the US, Canada, and Australia on Tubi, and worldwide on YouTube and Plex. It is also carried on just about every cable platform in the US, along with hotels, cruise ships, and more. "Pretty much anywhere you would like to watch the film, it's available," Pellerito said, "and we are incredibly proud of this."

And it is not only streaming. On the strength of the film's festival and digital success, "Moments of Youth" is now in the middle of a theatrical run, screening in the United States and Canada, with worldwide theaters in the works. On January 28, it screens at the historic Alex Theatre in Glendale, California, with Pellerito doing a Q&A afterward. "I am incredibly proud of the theatrical release," he said.

For anyone standing at their own crossroads

The last question we asked him was the one closest to the heart of the film. What does he hope a young person at their own turning point takes from it?

"Don't be afraid to dream," he said. "Whatever you can dream of, you can make possible. No matter what you're dealing with, there are not only good, but great people in this world who will do anything for you. Be comfortable leaning on them. Whether it's your parents, family, friends, coaches, teachers, people will be there. You can make it through anything and thrive while doing so."

Then, the sign off that could double as the film's whole thesis: "Dream away."