Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
National Sports

A Louisiana judge just gave the NCAA another black eye - and handed LSU a star

A Baton Rouge court ruled Monday in favor of RJ Luis Jr., the 2025 Big East Player of the Year, clearing him to suit up for LSU despite having signed NBA contracts. The decision could open a new path for professional players to return to college basketball.

A Louisiana judge just gave the NCAA another black eye - and handed LSU a star

The hearing ran nearly six hours inside the 19th Judicial District Courthouse in Baton Rouge. When it was over, RJ Luis Jr. walked out smiling.

A Louisiana judge on Monday granted Luis, the 2025 Big East Player of the Year, a temporary injunction to play for LSU this season despite signing multiple NBA contracts. The ruling by Judge Ronald Johnson in East Baton Rouge Parish was the outcome LSU and Luis had spent months working toward, and it landed like a punch on a governing body that has struggled all summer to hold its eligibility lines.

After starring for St. John's in 2024-25 and securing second-team All-American honors, Luis went undrafted in the 2025 NBA draft. He signed a two-way contract with the Jazz, and then an Exhibit 10 contract with the Celtics' G League affiliate after he was traded from Utah to Boston and later waived. Luis appeared in three preseason games with the Celtics before he was waived and inked an Exhibit 10 deal to play for their G-League affiliate, the Maine Celtics, but he missed all of last season with an injury. He never played a single regular-season game at any professional level.

That last fact was central to the argument his attorneys made in court. "What we have today is a decision by a judge to protect the future of a young man who has done nothing wrong," attorney Elliot Abrams said after the ruling. His co-counsel, Tony Clayton, went further. Clayton said the decision could set a precedent at the collegiate level. "It's monumental. I just think the NCAA has to follow this precedent here, that you've got to treat these kids the same, period," he said.

Luis committed to LSU on May 19 while pursuing another season of college eligibility. The situation put Will Wade - back at LSU after stints at McNeese and NC State - in an unusual position: building a roster that depended in part on the courts. The move is a significant addition for Wade and LSU, which had just four players on its official roster earlier this month. Wade was in the courtroom Monday and hugged Luis after the verdict came down.

The player himself is no marginal prospect chasing one last paycheck. Luis, a 6-foot-7 wing, averaged 18.2 points and 7.2 rebounds during the 2024-25 season. His arrival immediately raises the ceiling for LSU, which also has commitments from former UCLA teammates Donovan Dent and Skyy Clark. In the SEC, those numbers would make him one of the most dangerous wings in the conference on day one.

This is bigger than Luis and LSU

The NCAA fought this one hard. SEC commissioner Greg Sankey, in a court filing, spoke out against Luis and Kentucky commit Mark Mitchell, who had signed an Exhibit 10 contract before a local judge on Saturday cleared him to play. Sankey argued that maintaining eligibility rules was "essential to the integrity of college sports," according to Saturday Down South.

The NCAA has been losing this battle in state courts all summer. On Friday, the NCAA won its motion to reverse a federal preliminary injunction in Colorado that had created a blanket waiver for players in the 2022 high school class to play a fifth season. But it has lost the majority of cases at the state level in those eligibility cases.

Luis's situation, though, is different from the fifth-year eligibility wave. Luis is not a fifth-year player. His case, however, could create a new pipeline of players who have signed professional contracts and want to make their way back to college basketball and the millions of dollars available to them if they do. That is the piece that has college administrators genuinely rattled.

Luis' case could create a new influx of players who have signed professional contracts, even if they were in school years ago, to compete again at the collegiate level. The NCAA will likely fight this case. If the organization wants to continue its efforts to prevent Luis from playing this upcoming season, it can request a 'stay to pause the injunction' or utilize other methods as the clock ticks until the season begins.

NCAA president Charlie Baker had drawn a clear line back in December. "The NCAA has not and will not grant eligibility to any prospective or returning student-athletes who have signed an NBA contract (including a two-way contract)," Baker said in a statement. Monday's ruling stepped right over that line.

Wade's gamble is paying off - for now

Will Wade's return to LSU has been nothing if not aggressive. Wade has been unabashed this cycle with his roster-building efforts. LSU reportedly has a $5 million deal on the table for Israeli point guard Yam Madar, among other moves. Recruiting Luis knowing the odds were against him legally was the boldest swing of all.

It worked. Wade will have to rely on the courts to support his roster this season, as the bulk of his players will need court rulings to play - court rulings that could be challenged, potentially jeopardizing the standing of those players in the months ahead. That uncertainty hangs over everything. The injunction is temporary. The NCAA's next move could come any day.

For now, Luis is in. Judge Ronald Johnson oversaw Luis' lawsuit against the NCAA at the 19th Judicial District Courthouse in Baton Rouge on Monday, with the final verdict being revealed over five hours later. Attorney Clayton said: "I didn't want to hug him too long because I didn't want to cry. But I felt a big relief lift off that kid's shoulders."

Luis started at UMass, transferred to St. John's under Rick Pitino, went through the draft, bounced between Utah and Boston, sat out a full season hurt, and ended up in a Baton Rouge courtroom fighting for the right to play college basketball again. Now he'll try to do it in the SEC, in a Pete Maravich Assembly Center that will be watching closely - assuming the injunction survives whatever the NCAA files next.

Sources