Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
National Sports

An undrafted rookie from Maine is starting at quarterback for the Ravens on Thursday night

Lamar Jackson is on injured reserve with a thumb injury and Tyler Huntley's season is over after turf toe surgery, leaving Baltimore with no choice but to hand the offense to Joe Fagnano, a 25-year-old who was a walk-on at Maine four years ago.

Baltimore's season just got turned over to a 25-year-old who barely got drafted at all

In the span of one ugly afternoon in Buffalo, the Baltimore Ravens lost both of their quarterbacks. By Wednesday morning, they had official confirmation that they are not getting either one back anytime soon. Lamar Jackson is on injured reserve with a right thumb injury that requires surgery, and backup Tyler Huntley, per ESPN's Adam Schefter, has a season-ending turf toe injury. Thursday night against the Jacksonville Jaguars on Prime Video, the Ravens will start Joe Fagnano. He went undrafted in April. He played college ball at Maine and UConn. He has one NFL appearance on his resume, and in that appearance he went 10 for 21 for 91 yards with an interception and lost a fumble.

This is not a bridge situation. This could be the rest of the Ravens' season.

How it unraveled in one afternoon

Jackson sustained a thumb injury on the first play against Buffalo and was immediately replaced by Huntley, who also suffered an injury to his toe and exited the contest early, leaving Fagnano the only available quarterback on the roster. Fagnano was forced into the emergency third-string role in the Ravens' 36-10 loss to the Bills.

Coach Jesse Minter noted that Jackson and Huntley are likely both heading to injured reserve before Thursday's game, so this start against Jacksonville could be the first of many for Fagnano. That message landed Wednesday morning when Schefter reported that tests confirmed the season-ending turf toe injury for Huntley.

With Jackson expected to miss significant time and Huntley not practicing, the Ravens are down to Fagnano, Kedon Slovis and Austin Reed at quarterback. Baltimore signed Slovis off Green Bay's practice squad just to have a warm body in the building. Reed has played in exactly one NFL game in his career. The safety net here is thin.

Who is Joe Fagnano

The short version: a Williamsport, Pennsylvania kid who walked on at the University of Maine as an 18-year-old in 2019, earned a scholarship, started, and eventually transferred to UConn for a shot at a bigger stage. In college, Fagnano put together his best season in 2025 at UConn, throwing for 28 touchdowns and just one interception. After the 2022 season he transferred to UConn to become an FBS quarterback, though a shoulder injury ended his 2023 season early before he fully emerged in 2025.

Nobody drafted him. After going undrafted in the 2026 NFL draft, Fagnano signed with the Baltimore Ravens on April 28, 2026. He beat out fellow undrafted rookie Diego Pavia for a roster spot after completing 56 of 75 passes for 509 yards with three touchdowns and one interception in the preseason. The Ravens liked what they saw enough to keep him on the 53-man roster instead of stashing him on the practice squad, which probably would have meant losing him to waivers.

With his start Thursday, Fagnano will become only the second undrafted rookie to start a regular-season game for the Ravens. He joins Anthony Brown, who started for Baltimore in 2022. Only one undrafted quarterback, Cooper Rush, has made his first regular-season start in a prime-time game, that number rises to two Thursday when Fagnano takes the first snap.

He is also dealing with an ankle injury of his own. Fagnano played through the ankle problem against Buffalo and was limited Monday before practicing fully Tuesday.

What Fagnano said

He kept it short and direct at the podium. "You work a lot to get into this position," Fagnano said. "It's unfortunate to see what happened to Lamar and 'Snoop', especially being two guys that I look up to, since coming to the organization with the Ravens, have helped me out a ton. So that's part's tough."

On the short week: "Short week, first one I've been a part of. Quick turnaround going from Sunday to Thursday, but about how you expect. Watch the tape, get some corrections done, and then straight to the next."

His overall framing: "It's next-man-up mentality," Fagnano said about replacing Jackson and Huntley. That is about as boilerplate as it gets, but the situation behind it is anything but ordinary.

What this means for Baltimore's season

The Ravens came into Week 8 as a legitimate AFC contender. The Jaguars, at 3-5, are coming off a 5-2 start before a rough stretch that has taken some of the shine off Jacksonville. Baltimore's short week gives them almost no runway to install anything complex for Fagnano. The Ravens do not have a lot of time to prepare for Jacksonville, so acquiring a more experienced quarterback may not have made much difference this week.

The trade deadline is still open. The NFL's deadline, now set after Week 9, means Baltimore has a narrow window to bring in another quarterback. The 2026 NFL trade deadline falls a little over a week away, giving the front office time to assess Fagnano after Thursday and decide whether to add a veteran arm. Names like the 49ers' Mac Jones have already circulated in trade notebooks.

What nobody wants to say out loud in Owings Mills: if Jackson needs weeks of recovery after thumb surgery, and Huntley's turf toe truly cost him the rest of the year, Baltimore's playoff picture changes fast. The AFC is deep. Carrying a quarterback room anchored by an undrafted 25-year-old with 91 career passing yards is not a path most teams survive.

For now, Fagnano is the answer. On Thursday night, the undrafted UConn product goes from simulating plays in his living room with his wife to making his first NFL start against the Jacksonville Jaguars, having spent most of the season doing exactly that at home to stay sharp.

Sources