Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
Pop Culture

Anne Hathaway's 'Verity' crushes Tom Cruise's 'Digger' in one of the most lopsided October box office weekends in years

The Colleen Hoover adaptation opened to an estimated $33.6M while Cruise's $125M-to-$180M satirical swing landed with a thud around $8M, his worst debut since 2007.

Anne Hathaway owns October again as 'Digger' craters

The numbers came in this weekend and they are not close. Variety reports that Verity, the psychological thriller starring Anne Hathaway, Dakota Johnson, and Josh Hartnett, opened to an estimated $33.6 million domestically across 3,510 theaters for Amazon MGM. Across town, Tom Cruise's Digger pulled in around $8 million from 3,321 screens for Warner Bros., a number that, by any measure, constitutes a wreck.

A "chick lit" thriller starring an Oscar winner out-earned one of the biggest box office stars of all time in what must have been seen, at some point, as an awards-season contender. Deadline called it "the worst Tom Cruise film opening in 19 years."

The gap between the two movies is brutal. Hathaway's film opened in 3,510 North American theaters and had already made $4.5 million from previews alone, then brought in around $14.5 million on Friday. The film earned $15.1 million from those 3,510 theaters on Friday, with weekend estimates now placing Verity at approximately $33.6 million.

Warner Bros.' Digger grossed an estimated $8 million during its opening weekend, according to box office tracking from Exhibitor Relations Co. Directed by Alejandro G. Iñárritu and starring Tom Cruise, the film collected just $3.4 million on its opening Friday, which included $1.2 million in Thursday night preview screenings.

That opening makes Digger Tom Cruise's lowest box office debut since 2007's Lions for Lambs. A long-range forecast from Box Office Pro had originally put the film between $20 million and $30 million, later revised to $12 million to $15 million, while Box Office Theory forecast $7.5 million to $12.5 million, and some rivals had Digger in the high single digits. It landed at the bottom of all of those ranges.

The budget math is grim for Warner Bros.

Cruise plays Digger Rockwell, a blowhard oil tycoon whose company causes an ecological disaster that threatens humanity. The film's budget reportedly grew from an original $125 million to between $160 million and $180 million, putting its break-even point at around $350 million.

Warner Bros. has disputed the reported production cost, with the studio claiming the break-even point is closer to $300 million, making the film's financial success uncertain. Either way, an $8 million domestic opening weekend is not the start anyone was drawing up.

The movie is Iñárritu's first English-language feature since The Revenant and Cruise's first movie with Warner Bros. since 2014's Edge of Tomorrow. For Warners, it's a stark reversal from the studio's 2025 slate, which included "Sinners," "A Minecraft Movie," and "Weapons."

Critics split, but the box office didn't

The reviews did not help. Digger debuted on Rotten Tomatoes with a 52% rating based on 67 reviews, and Metacritic has it at 45, categorized as mixed or average based on 56 critic reviews.

The critics who liked it, really liked it. The London Evening Standard called it a 5-out-of-5 "audacious, risky, terrific fun." Those who didn't were merciless. One two-star review called it "a grand, audacious muddle, part Terry Gilliam's 'Brazil,' part Stanley Kubrick's 'Dr. Strangelove,' desperately flailing and screeching in trying to reach a profound conclusion."

Self-indulgence and excessive length were among the largest criticisms of Iñárritu's prior film Bardo, and those same tendencies reportedly persist here, with scenes that linger far too long and stretch moments of intended impact to the point of exhaustion.

In the face of withering reviews, Tom Cruise launched a charm offensive to salvage the film's awards chances. At an FYC screening, Cruise made a passionate plea for more "real" films. Cruise, Iñárritu, and cast members Riz Ahmed, John Goodman, Jesse Plemons, Michael Stuhlbarg, and Sandra Hüller turned up at an FYC event at the Academy Museum of Motion Pictures in Los Angeles, in an attempt to rewrite the narrative before an audience of guild members and awards voters.

The film holds a 53% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and a 44 score on Metacritic, the worst of Iñárritu's career. The film's once sky-high Oscar odds have taken a tumble since the first reactions started to trickle out of early screenings.

'Verity' keeps Hoover's box office streak alive, sort of

The Colleen Hoover adaptation stars Hathaway as bestselling author Verity Crawford, with Dakota Johnson playing Lowen Ashleigh and Josh Hartnett as Jeremy Crawford. The opening is especially notable because Verity entered the weekend with mixed reviews.

Verity was produced for $40 million and will help Amazon MGM rebound after this summer's "Masters of the Universe," which flopped with $113 million globally against a $200 million budget. At $33.6 million, the film is already nearly at break-even before international returns are counted.

This gives Hathaway her third number-one movie at the box office in 2026, following The Devil Wears Prada 2 and The Odyssey. Hoover has been adapted for the big screen before, with It Ends with Us ($50M domestic opening), Regretting You ($13.6M), and Reminders of Him ($17.8M), all three more in the weepy romance mode than the edgier Verity.

Gold Derby notes that Hathaway is closing out a year that has grossed over $2.5 billion. That is a 2026 nobody predicted for her.

As for Cruise, his next film with Hathaway is already in the pipeline. Before the two went head-to-head this weekend, they were announced as co-stars in Days of Thunder 2. How the implosion of Digger affects the momentum of that production is a conversation Warner Bros. is probably having right now.

Sources