Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
National Sports

Cleveland's quarterback call is finally here, and Todd Monken has to live with it

The Cleveland Browns will name their Week 1 starting quarterback Monday, ending one of the messiest and most-watched QB battles of the preseason. Shedeur Sanders or Deshaun Watson - one answer, no do-overs.

Cleveland's quarterback call is finally here, and Todd Monken has to live with it

Monday is the day. After two months of training camp reps, joint practices with the Bills, and a preseason schedule that produced more heat than clarity, Browns head coach Todd Monken will name his Week 1 starting quarterback. CBS Sports confirmed Sunday that Sanders will learn Monday if he or Deshaun Watson will start at quarterback for the Browns, per ESPN's Jeremy Fowler. It is a genuinely consequential football decision - one that will shape Cleveland's entire 2026 season and, depending on who gets the call, could blow up the franchise's long-term rebuilding plan before Labor Day weekend.

The competition has not been clean. Neither quarterback has separated himself cleanly. The two signal-callers have alternated starting reps so far this preseason, with Watson starting the first half of Cleveland's preseason opener while Sanders started in Saturday's 31-7 preseason loss to Buffalo. That score should scare nobody who follows the Browns closely - Cleveland's starters were mostly parked on the sideline - but the individual numbers told a story.

The 24-year-old Sanders outplayed Watson during the second exhibition, going 9-for-11 passing for 74 yards, one touchdown and one interception, but neither quarterback has obviously pulled away in the competition this preseason. Specifically, Sanders opened the game with eight consecutive completions and directed Cleveland's only scoring drive despite playing without most of the Browns' established starters.

Watson, meanwhile, had a rougher afternoon and heard it from the crowd. Sanders publicly defended Watson after the home crowd reacted negatively during Saturday's loss to the Bills. Although Sanders is in a competitive race for the starting quarterback position, he made it clear to reporters that he did not approve of fans booing Watson. That is a notable moment. The rookie, fighting for Watson's job, went out of his way to shield him. Whatever Monken decides Monday, the locker room dynamic between the two players seems far less toxic than the outside noise.

Word on the team's Week 1 starter is on track to arrive Monday via Monken, while both Sanders and Watson are not slated to play in Thursday's preseason finale against New England. The plan is to use that final exhibition as a dress rehearsal for whoever gets the nod - a chance for the starter to run a full game-prep week with the first team before the regular season opens.

What's actually at stake

This is not a typical depth chart fight. Watson carries a fully guaranteed contract that has cost Cleveland hundreds of millions of dollars even as he has struggled with injuries and inconsistent play in recent seasons. While Watson's fully guaranteed contract and extensive experience initially made him the favorite to start the season, Sanders' composed performances and sharp execution have turned this into one of the most closely contested battles in the league.

For Sanders, it's equally loaded. The Colorado product was taken in last year's draft and has waited his turn. His social media presence after Saturday's game was precise: Sanders shared several photos from the 31-7 preseason loss to the Bills, captioning the post simply, "$²." No lengthy statement. No lobbying. Two characters, and anyone paying attention knew what they meant.

Whether Sanders or Watson is named the Week 1 starter, they will likely be on a short leash throughout the 2026 campaign. That is the uncomfortable reality inside Berea. Monken is a first-year head coach in Cleveland who inherited this situation. He did not create the Watson contract. He did not draft Sanders. He has, however, spent the summer managing both quarterbacks carefully enough that both men still believe they can win the job - which is either excellent roster management or a sign that the decision genuinely wasn't obvious.

League analysts have started to weigh in. ESPN analyst Jeremy Fowler described the situation as "essentially over," opening up about the Browns' stance on Watson and Sanders as Monken weighs the QB1 decision. Watson reportedly held the lead in the competition from late April through last Thursday's joint practice with the Bills. But late April was a long time ago. Camp performance has a way of reshuffling things.

The broader preseason picture

The Browns' QB situation was the loudest story out of Sunday's final wave of NFL preseason news, but it wasn't the only thing happening around the league. In Las Vegas, the Raiders got a scare of a different kind. Raiders running back Ashton Jeanty was helped off the practice field Sunday without putting any weight on his right leg. The second-year rusher had been having a strong practice when he landed awkwardly diving for a catch thrown by Kirk Cousins during 11-on-11 drills.

The entire Raiders team took a knee and said a prayer. That detail says a lot about how serious the scene looked in real time. The relief came hours later. Jeanty is believed to have sprained his ankle, per sources who spoke to ESPN's Adam Schefter and Ian Rapoport. The Raiders are still unsure how long he will be out, but it is not considered a long-term injury.

First-year head coach Klint Kubiak is expected to make Jeanty the centerpiece of the offense this season alongside tight end Brock Bowers. In 17 games as a rookie last year, Jeanty finished with 1,321 yards from scrimmage - 975 rushing, 346 receiving on 55 catches - with 10 total touchdowns. Losing him for any stretch of September would significantly alter Las Vegas's offensive identity heading into Week 1 against Miami. That Raiders-Dolphins opener is three weeks from Sunday.

The two stories - Cleveland's quarterback call and Las Vegas's running back health - together capture the specific anxiety that hangs over every NFL team right now. One week from roster cutdowns, franchises are making decisions that will either look shrewd or deeply wrong by mid-October. Monken's answer Monday puts Cleveland on one of those two tracks.

Browns offensive coordinator Todd Monken was not ready to name a starting quarterback immediately after Saturday's game. The competition had continued all summer, with Sanders getting the preseason start against Buffalo and Watson hearing boos from fans. The silence since Saturday has only intensified the anticipation. When Monken speaks Monday in Berea, Ohio, every word will be parsed.

Sanders has spent the weekend posting weights on social media. Watson has said nothing public. Somewhere in the Browns' facility, Monken has already made up his mind - and the rest of Cleveland is just waiting for him to say it out loud.

Sources