Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
National Sports

Jaxson Dart's MCL scare puts Giants right back on the clock, and Jameis Winston is their answer for now

The second-year Giants quarterback left Monday Night Football in the first quarter with a sprained knee, and New York's offense collapsed around Jameis Winston in a 28-6 rout at SoFi Stadium.

Dart goes down on the opening drive, and the Giants fall apart fast

Five minutes into Monday Night Football in Inglewood, and the New York Giants' season got complicated again. Quarterback Jaxson Dart took a hard shot from Rams defenders Josaiah Stewart and Byron Young on a third-and-8 pass attempt, and when he landed, his left knee bent inward in a way that made the SoFi Stadium crowd go quiet. Dart was hit mid-throw, his left knee bent awkwardly in the air, and he fell to the ground grabbing at it in pain before walking off the field without assistance.

New York Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart is believed to have sustained a sprained MCL in the first quarter of Monday's 28-6 loss to the Los Angeles Rams, per NFL Network's Ian Rapoport based on initial exams. X-rays were negative, according to sources, and Dart will undergo an MRI on Tuesday. He is expected to miss some time.

The most relieving part, at least for now: it does not appear to be a torn ACL. If Tuesday's MRI confirms that Dart only suffered an MCL sprain, the injury will not be season-ending, and he will have a chance to come back at some point in 2026. The most likely recovery window falls in the two-to-six-week range pending the final MRI grade.

Head coach John Harbaugh was asked about it directly after the game. "We'll know more Tuesday," Harbaugh said. Regarding the reported MCL sprain, he added: "That's in the neighborhood of it. We'll get an MRI Tuesday and have a real good feel for it." General manager Joe Schoen expressed optimism, and early indications suggest Dart should hold on as the 2026 season moves forward.

Dart apparently tried to talk his way back into the game. It didn't work. He eventually returned to the sideline in street clothes after halftime and walked with the team postgame without a notable limp.

Winston steps in. It goes about as well as you'd expect.

Jameis Winston took the snaps from that point forward. The Giants' night did not improve. Winston was set to hold down the fort while Dart recovered, but he completed just 11 of 27 pass attempts for 111 yards and one interception and consistently missed receivers.

Veteran Jameis Winston took over, but the gap in quality was evident as the Giants looked out of sorts. The final score was 28 to 6. That says everything about how the rest of the night went.

The Rams, meanwhile, were sharp. Matthew Stafford registered a passer rating of 131.3, completing 22 of 31 passes for 327 yards and four touchdowns with one interception. Davante Adams logged eight catches for 195 yards and two touchdowns during the win, and Los Angeles did all of that without wide receiver Puka Nacua. It was Adams' 29th career game with multiple receiving touchdowns, tied for fourth most in NFL history.

Stafford also crossed a personal milestone. The Rams quarterback is now sixth on the NFL's all-time career passing touchdowns list, passing Philip Rivers according to ESPN's game coverage from ESPN.

Aaron Donald, returning to action as well, played 32 defensive snaps (58.2 percent of the defensive snaps) and was credited with three tackles, one run stuff and no quarterback pressures. That production line will get scrutinized going forward, but the Rams won the game and that is what matters this week.

The bigger picture: it keeps happening to young quarterbacks

Dart joining the injury list is not an isolated incident. It is the latest entry in a rough stretch for the league's most prominent young signal-callers. Caleb Williams, the 2024 No. 1 overall pick, left a Week 2 loss to the Minnesota Vikings with a hamstring injury and is being considered week-to-week. Washington's Jayden Daniels, the 2024 No. 2 overall pick, suffered a dislocated elbow in a loss to the Dallas Cowboys, the same injury that cost him four games in the 2025 regular season. Dart, the 2025 first-round pick out of Ole Miss, is now week-to-week himself.

The Giants at 1-1 are not in crisis. But there is a real gap between what they look like with Dart under center and what they look like without him. The drop-off significantly dims their playoff odds if the MRI comes back worse than the initial read. The week-to-week tag is the best-case scenario right now.

For the Rams, the win gets them to 1-1 after avoiding a possibly disastrous 0-2 start by returning home from a beating in Australia to put a beating on the Giants. The Stafford-Adams combination looks like the engine Sean McVay was counting on.

Tuesday's MRI will tell New York how long it needs Winston to be the starter. The medical staff's findings will establish whether Dart can return quickly to spearhead New York's offense or whether Winston must prepare for an extended stint as the primary starter. The Giants face the Tennessee Titans in Week 3, then the Arizona Cardinals in Week 4 at MetLife. A week of practice with the starters will need to get Winston more in rhythm for the Week 3 matchup against the Titans.

Dart flew back east on the team plane. The MRI appointment is Tuesday morning.

Sources