Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
National Sports

Michigan needed a ghost second and a Hail Mary to survive Western Michigan. The Big Ten has some explaining to do.

Bryce Underwood threw a 47-yard touchdown to JJ Buchanan after officials controversially added a second back on the clock - giving No. 16 Michigan a 13-12 win that Western Michigan and most of the country believe they never should have lost.

Michigan needed a ghost second and a Hail Mary to survive Western Michigan. The Big Ten has some explaining to do.

The clock hit zero. Western Michigan started storming the field. And then, somehow, there was still time left.

That sequence - equal parts absurd and infuriating depending on your allegiances - defined the chaotic opening night of the 2026 college football season at Michigan Stadium in Ann Arbor. Bryce Underwood connected with JJ Buchanan on a 47-yard touchdown pass that lifted No. 16 Michigan over Western Michigan, 13-12, on Saturday night. But the final score tells almost none of the story.

On Saturday night in his debut as Michigan head coach, former Utah head coach Kyle Whittingham was headed for a 12-7 upset loss to the Western Michigan Broncos of the MAC when officials bailed him and his team out. The Wolverines were 27.5-point favorites. They got out-coached for 59 minutes and 55 seconds.

What actually happened

With seven seconds left in the fourth quarter, the Wolverines trailed 12-7 and had the ball at Western Michigan's 47-yard line. A Hail Mary attempt by Underwood went past the back of the end zone as time ran out - officials reviewed the play and put one second on the clock. On Michigan's second Hail Mary, Buchanan hauled in a deep pass from Underwood for the game-winning touchdown.

WMU players were already on the field celebrating when officials called for a review. TV replays showed the clock hitting zero before the ball hit the hands of a Western Michigan defender, but officials ruled there was a second still to play.

NBC rules analyst Terry McAulay did not hide his skepticism. "The ball isn't even close to touching a player when it goes to zero," McAulay said on the broadcast. "Their Hawk-Eye system apparently had a different sync... I don't see how that happened, assuming our clock is correct."

Western Michigan head coach Lance Taylor was measured but unmistakable about what he saw. "I know when I looked up at the clock, it was past zeros before we touched it," Taylor said. "I knew that they would review it; it was the last play of the game. Because we defended it so well, I wasn't worried or concerned about our guys going out and defending it a second time. Unfortunately, we did not defend it as well the second time." After Taylor's comments, the Big Ten released a statement and video explaining the decision to put a second back on.

Without the context of the NBC broadcast, the replay video is convincing - but ultimately the Big Ten's explanation doesn't explain why the synced clock on the NBC broadcast pretty clearly hit 0:00 before a Western Michigan defender deflected the ball. MAC commissioner Dr. John A. Steinbrecher accepted the Big Ten's findings in a statement issued early Sunday morning, saying "the Big Ten subsequently provided video and audio of the replay, which confirmed the explanation provided to us."

A brutal night for the Wolverines - before the miracle

The Broncos kicked four field goals and forced three turnovers, including a late fumble by Underwood. Western Michigan went ahead for the first time early in the fourth quarter on Dieter Kelly's 39-yard field goal that capped a 20-play drive that took 13:40 off the clock. Michigan's offense had no answer for it.

Underwood finished 12-of-22 for 170 yards and one touchdown while throwing one interception. He also picked up a team-high 47 yards and one score on the ground, but lost a fumble in the fourth quarter. Buchanan ended the game as Michigan's leading receiver, catching six passes for 126 yards to go along with the final touchdown.

Michigan finished the night with just 12 total first downs. For most of the evening, the offense looked like a team still learning its own playbook - which, in fairness, it largely is.

Whittingham didn't spin it. "This game will go down in Michigan history," he said after the game. "I don't know if it'll be positive history. We have a lot of things to fix. We didn't stop the run, run the ball well or win the turnover margin, get enough first downs."

A new era that immediately has questions

Whittingham, who spent 21 seasons as head coach at Utah, replaced Sherrone Moore, who was fired in December after an inappropriate relationship with a staff member. Following 21 seasons as Utah's head coach, Whittingham looks to bring much-needed stability to the Michigan program. One of college football's greatest traditions experienced back-to-back deflating campaigns after 2023's national championship.

Saturday night did not supply the reassurance the Michigan fan base was looking for. Western Michigan was threatening to hand Michigan perhaps its biggest upset since a season-opening loss to Appalachian State in 2007, when the Wolverines were 33-point favorites. The opponent was different. The helpless feeling in Ann Arbor felt familiar.

Underwood, for his part, kept the focus off the clock and on the throw. "The thought was give my guys an opportunity, and that's what I did," Underwood said after the game. "Excitement, we built a lot of trust over the last eight or nine months. So, I gave him an opportunity and he made the play." Underwood also revealed that Michigan practiced Hail Marys several times in the week leading up to the game.

Meanwhile, across the country Saturday night, LSU rolled Clemson 51-10 in Baton Rouge, a result that immediately reshuffled the top of the polls. That performance was dominant and unambiguous. The Michigan win was neither. The Wolverines were favored by 27.5 points and are set to host SEC foe Oklahoma next weekend. Michigan will still have plenty of concerns to address moving forward.

The Big Ten's Hawk-Eye timing system is now under a microscope it did not expect to face in Week 1. Western Michigan's players went from a sideline sprint in celebration to a locker room with nothing. The outcome left Western Michigan distraught and left the Big Ten officiating crew with questions to answer about a confounding call that appeared to have no justification in the moment.

JJ Buchanan has a touchdown. Lance Taylor has a case. And the 2026 college football season is exactly one game old.

Sources