Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
National News

Senate Republicans' rush to confirm Trump judges is running into Senate Republicans

With six weeks left before Democrats take the gavel, Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley is pushing an aggressive confirmation calendar. His own colleagues are already blocking nominees.

Senate Republicans arrived back in Washington this week with one overriding judicial goal: pack as many of President Donald Trump's court nominees onto the federal bench as possible before Democrats seize the committee gavels in January. By Wednesday, the plan had already hit a wall, and the obstruction was coming from inside the Republican caucus.

The specific flashpoint: Oklahoma. Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley was forced to postpone a key committee vote Tuesday on Oklahoma judicial nominee Zachary West because of opposition from Sen. Thom Tillis, acting on behalf of appointed Oklahoma Sen. Alan Armstrong. The opposition may be only temporary. Armstrong had initially approved of the pick but recently reversed course, privately conveying his opposition to other senators, according to two people with knowledge of the talks.

Armstrong said Wednesday that his objections were "just purely qualification, versus the other candidates that we've suggested," and said the White House "basically ignored" other recommended candidates for the vacancy. The White House is not backing down. An official told CNN that "the President has selected two highly qualified nominees for the district court in Oklahoma, and we are confident they will be confirmed."

Oklahoma is not the only problem. The stalemates already forced a switcheroo this week of Trump's choice for an appeals court seat, potentially slowing down the timeline for filling it, while at least one other district court nomination in Oklahoma may be imperiled because of resistance from a Republican home-state senator.

The broader push

The Democrats' coming takeover of the Senate has kickstarted a scramble to confirm roughly two dozen of Trump's judicial nominees before Republicans turn over the gavel in January. Senate Republicans are racing to fill as many federal court vacancies as possible while they still have the votes. Republicans have already confirmed 56 Article III judges during Trump's second term, according to the Senate Republican Conference.

Grassley set the tone publicly, writing in a Wall Street Journal op-ed published November 10 that "under my leadership, the Judiciary Committee has moved judicial confirmations at the fastest pace since the Reagan administration," and that he has "scheduled two hearings within an eight-day span this month to consider district and appellate nominees." The goal is straightforward: get as many nominees as possible confirmed in the limited window that remains.

Senate Republican Whip John Barrasso of Wyoming left little ambiguity about the plan. "We're going to make every second count, and that means all these judicial appointments," Barrasso said Tuesday.

Grassley was blunt about why the urgency is so high. "They're planning to stonewall a president's ability to appoint judges. So yes, I'm working. I'm going to work hard to get judges confirmed quickly during the lame duck session," Grassley said at Tuesday's committee meeting.

Democrats push back on the process

Democrats are not simply watching. Sen. Dick Durbin of Illinois, the top Democrat on the Judiciary Committee, accused Republicans of cutting corners, criticizing shortened review periods and the committee's decision to proceed with hearings before FBI background checks had been cleared by Senate staff.

Democrats have pointed to norms around having judicial hearings at least two weeks apart. A plan for a November 18 hearing comes after a confirmation hearing on November 10. They have also cited the committee's standard of giving senators at least 28 days to review Senate Judiciary Questionnaires submitted with nominations.

Once Republicans get the nominees out of committee and onto the Senate floor, Democrats still have leverage in slowing down the process. Historically, the parties have been able to reach deals at the end of a Congress, when senators are eager to get home for the holidays, that allow for quick confirmation of some nominees in exchange for leaving others behind. Whether that holds this cycle, with relations between the two parties stretched thin after a bruising midterm, is an open question.

The calendar is merciless

Time is the Republicans' real enemy. Under normal Senate timelines, nominees need to get their confirmation hearing before the committee by next week if Republicans want to get them on the Senate floor by mid-December, before lawmakers leave for the holidays. And the judicial calendar is competing with everything else on the lame-duck agenda.

The current continuing resolution expires December 11, and none of the 12 annual appropriations bills for FY2027 have been enacted. That funding deadline could consume days that Republicans want for confirmations. On top of that, Republicans are weighing a debt-limit increase before Democrats take over, which would remove a borrowing deadline that analysts say could arrive in early to mid-2027 as a source of leverage against Trump. Senate Majority Leader John Thune has said it could come in the lame duck.

But a debt-limit vote faces its own Republican opposition. Sen. Thom Tillis said flatly that Thune lacks the votes to do a debt ceiling increase through reconciliation. "Unless I see a booking of all the savings from DOGE, or some other major rescissions or recommended spending cuts, I'm not gonna vote for a debt ceiling increase in this Congress," Tillis said.

Dozens of House lawmakers and at least 17 senators are leaving Congress, raising questions about attendance, cooperation and how much work departing members actually want to do. Democrats cannot block the confirmations outright, because Republicans need only a majority and control the schedule. But majority math gets thin fast when members decide the airport is more appealing than the Senate floor in mid-December.

Central to the intraparty friction are Cornyn and Tillis, both of whom serve on the Judiciary Committee and are using their leverage to effectively block nominations on behalf of Republicans who aren't on the panel. Though it comes after the midterm losses that weakened Trump's political standing, this under-the-radar judiciary fight is more about Republicans asserting their powers over the administration's judge selections, which has long been a cherished prerogative for senators, particularly for their home states.

When Democrats take over, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island is expected to assume the chairmanship of the Judiciary Committee. At that point, the queue of unconfirmed Trump nominees effectively closes.

As for Zachary West in Oklahoma: newly elected Sen. Kevin Hern is scheduled to be sworn in on November 30. Whether Hern clears the path or keeps Armstrong's objection alive is now one of the more concrete variables in a confirmation process that is anything but predictable.

What to Watch

  • November 18 hearing: The Judiciary Committee has a confirmation hearing scheduled for November 18, just eight days after a prior hearing on November 10. Democrats will likely use procedural challenges to argue the compressed timeline violates Senate norms. Watch whether Grassley holds the date or blinks.
  • Kevin Hern's swearing-in (Nov. 30): The newly elected Oklahoma senator takes his seat at the end of the month. His stance on Zachary West's nomination will determine whether that seat can be filled before the December recess.
  • December 11 funding deadline: Congress must replace the current stopgap by December 11. Floor time spent on a government funding bill is floor time not spent confirming judges, and leadership has not publicly explained how it intends to sequence both.
  • Debt ceiling vote count: Thune wants to move a debt-limit increase before Democrats arrive. A funding bill needs 60 votes in the Senate, requiring Democratic buy-in, while a reconciliation route needs only a simple majority, though Republicans have a narrow margin. If Tillis and other deficit hawks hold firm, the ceiling vote may collapse entirely.
  • Jeffries leadership elections (Nov. 18 to 19): House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries is navigating tensions within his party ahead of the caucus's November 18 to 19 leadership elections, as he eyes the Speaker's gavel for January. How Democrats organize in those two days will shape their posture through the rest of the lame-duck fight.

Sources: CNN | Press Democrat / AP | Senate Judiciary Committee (Grassley op-ed) | Daily Wire | HNGN | Washington Sun | Fortune | The Hill

Frequently asked questions

How many judges are Republicans trying to confirm?

Senate Republicans are aiming to confirm roughly two dozen of Trump's judicial nominees before Democrats take control of the Senate in January, according to CNN and the Daily Wire.

Why are some Republican senators blocking their own party's nominees?

GOP senators John Cornyn and Thom Tillis are using their Judiciary Committee seats to block nominees they say the White House chose without consulting home-state senators, an assertion of the traditional senatorial prerogative known as blue-slip courtesy.

What is the deadline Republicans are working against?

The government's current continuing resolution expires December 11, and the new Democratic Senate majority is sworn in in early January, leaving Republicans a narrow window to both fund the government and push through confirmations.