Washington, DC/--°
Updating
Subscribe free
Pop Culture

Shane Gillis finally addresses his SNL gym joke, and the fallout is somehow still going

A month after his October 10 monologue set off a chain reaction of celebrity pile-ons and an on-air clapback from the next host, the comedian went on Joe Rogan to explain himself.

Shane Gillis finally addresses his SNL gym joke, and the fallout is somehow still going

A month is a long time in the internet's attention economy, but Shane Gillis and his October 10 Saturday Night Live monologue are not going quietly. On that episode, the comedian's opening monologue included jokes about how women "dress like whores now" at the gym, and the blast radius has been spreading ever since. This weekend, he finally talked about it.

Gillis addressed the backlash to his Saturday Night Live monologue on the November 13 episode of Joe Rogan's podcast. It was his first real public comment on the controversy. What he said did not exactly close the book.

What Gillis told Rogan

"Not to defend SNL, they don't approve it," Gillis said while appearing on the November 13 episode of The Joe Rogan Experience, revealing that SNL personnel did not pre-approve his remarks. "I mean, they could shut it down."

He also said he had told the show before taking the stage: "I'm giving you a solid C minus of a monologue, but I promise there's no controversy." The promise did not hold.

One of Rogan's co-hosts pointed out that Gillis had performed the same joke at New York City's Comedy Cellar the week before his SNL appearance, to which Gillis said: "Not to defend SNL, they don't approve it. They have writers that write the monologue for them."

As for the substance of the joke itself, Gillis blamed the backlash on the current "climate" and clarified that he doesn't "have a problem" with women's gym attire. According to Variety, Gillis said he was surprised by the blowback.

The chain reaction that preceded it

By the time Gillis sat down with Rogan, the original joke had already spawned its own celebrity news cycle. Dan Levy, the actor and creator of Schitt's Creek, uploaded an Instagram video criticizing the joke and blaming SNL for airing it, saying: "Women wearing short shorts at the gym does not make them whores."

Former SNL cast member Ego Nwodim posted an Instagram story of herself at the gym with the caption, "Wh, reporting for duty." Cecily Strong also drew criticism from several celebrities including former cast members.

Then came the in-studio response. Actress Inde Navarrette took a swipe at Gillis in her own SNL monologue on October 31, joking that she regularly wears a "little whore outfit" for gym training in preparation to star in the X-Men reboot. According to Complex, Navarrette flipped the controversial joke into a crowd-pleasing moment when she hosted SNL.

The debate did not stop inside the building. Gillis drew criticism from celebrities including actor Dan Levy and former SNL cast member Ego Nwodim. British comedian Jimmy Carr defended Gillis, arguing, as reported in the New York Post, that "intent is much more important than content" and that Gillis had been "trying to make people laugh." SNL cast member Michael Che reportedly shrugged off the controversy, while Kenan Thompson said creative freedom has limits "when one comedian's controversial jokes overshadow the rest of the SNL cast."

Gillis and SNL have history

The October 10 episode was Gillis's third time hosting SNL, which itself is a strange number given how the relationship started. Gillis has faced scrutiny over his comedy before: NBC removed him from the SNL cast in 2019, before his first scheduled season, following the resurfacing of racist remarks. He came back to host in 2024, then again in 2025, and now again this fall.

Gillis' remarks sparked intense backlash online, with many Hollywood stars speaking out in opposition to the comedian's remarks. Per People, among those who fired back was Gillis' ex-girlfriend, Grace Brassel, who claimed in an Instagram reel that she was "stripped" of her autonomy during their relationship. Gillis has not publicly addressed Brassel's claims.

The Rogan appearance has itself kicked off a fresh round of argument online, with supporters reading Gillis's explanation as reasonable and critics pointing out that the joke had already been done at the Comedy Cellar before anyone at 30 Rock could object to it. More than a month after his latest Saturday Night Live monologue sparked outrage, Gillis addressed the backlash, saying he had promised the show there would be "no controversy" before taking the stage. He called his own monologue "a solid C minus." He may have been underselling the drama it generated.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

What did Shane Gillis say in his SNL monologue that caused the backlash?

During his October 10 hosting appearance, Gillis joked that he hadn't been to the gym in so long, he didn't realize women "dress like whores now," a line that immediately drew criticism online and from several celebrities.

Who spoke out against Gillis after the monologue?

Dan Levy, former SNL cast members Ego Nwodim and Cecily Strong, and actress Inde Navarrette all publicly responded, with Navarrette flipping the joke during her own SNL hosting debut on Halloween.

What did Gillis say to Joe Rogan about the SNL approval process?

Gillis told Rogan that SNL producers did not pre-approve his monologue, saying "Not to defend SNL, they don't approve it. I mean, they could shut it down." He also said he had promised the show there would be "no controversy."